MyData:What Is MyData? | Login/Account Info | Download Saved Files | Logout
Description & Citation--Study No. 9982 | |
Bibliographic Description | |
| ICPSR Study No.: | 9982 |
|---|---|
| Persistent URL: | http://dx.doi.org/10.3886/ICPSR09982 |
| Title: | Evaluating Alternative Police Responses to Spouse Assault in Colorado Springs: an Enhanced Replication of the Minneapolis Experiment, 1987-1989 |
| Principal Investigator(s): | Howard Black, Colorado Springs Police Department |
| Richard Berk, Colorado Springs Police Department | |
| James Lily, Colorado Springs Police Department | |
| Robert Owenbey, Colorado Springs Police Department | |
| Giannina Rikoski, Colorado Springs Police Department | |
| Funding Agency: | United States Department of Justice. National Institute of Justice. |
| Grant Number: | 86-IJ-CX-0045 |
| Bibliographic Citation: | Black, Howard, Richard Berk, James Lily, Robert Owenbey, and Giannina Rikoski. EVALUATING ALTERNATIVE POLICE RESPONSES TO SPOUSE ASSAULT IN COLORADO SPRINGS: AN ENHANCED REPLICATION OF THE MINNEAPOLIS EXPERIMENT, 1987-1989 [Computer file]. Compiled by Howard Black, Richard Berk, James Lily, Robert Owenbey, and Giannina Rikoski, Colorado Springs Police Department. ICPSR ed. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research [producer and distributor], 1994. |
Scope of Study | |
| Summary: | The purpose of this study was to replicate an experiment in Minneapolis (MINNEAPOLIS INTERVENTION PROJECT, 1986-1987 [ICPSR 9808]) testing alternative police response to cases of spouse assault, using a larger number of subjects and a more complex research design. The study focused on how police response affected subsequent incidents of spouse assault. Police responses studied included arrest, issuing emergency protection orders, referring the suspect to counseling, separating the suspect and the victim, and restoring order only (no specific action). Data were obtained through initial incident reports, counseling information, and personal interviews. Follow-up interviews were conducted at three- and six-month periods, and recidivists were identified through police and court record checks. Variables from initial incident reports include number of charges, date, location, and disposition of charges, weapon(s) used, victim injuries, medical attention received, behavior towards police, victim and suspect comments, and demographic information such as race, sex, relationship to victim/offender, age, and past victim/offender history. Data collected from counseling forms provide information on demographic characteristics of the suspect, type of counseling, topics covered in counseling, suspect's level of participation, and therapist comments. Court records investigate victim and suspect criminal histories, including descriptions of charges and their disposition, conditions of pretrial release, and the victim's contact with pretrial services. Other variables included in follow-up checks focus on criminal and offense history of the suspect. The data collection includes separate data files for the original, second, and final versions of some of the forms that were used. |
| Subject Term(s): | arrests, counseling, crisis intervention, domestic assault, intervention, intervention strategies, police intervention, police response, recidivism, spouse abuse, victims |
| Geographic Coverage: | Colorado, Colorado Springs, United States |
| Time Period: | March 1987 - April 1989 |
| Date(s) of Collection: | 1987 - 1989 |
| Unit of Observation: | Incidents, individuals, and court cases. |
| Universe: | All domestic violence calls made to the Colorado Springs Police Department between March 1987 and April 1989. |
| Data Type: | survey data, and event/transaction data |
| Data Collection Notes: | All variables over two columns wide may contain values of ''-22'', ''-66'', ''-77'', ''-99'', ''X''. These values may or may not be documented in the codebook. All alphanumeric variables over seven columns wide with these same values are not listed in the ''MISSING VALUE RECODE'' nor in the ''MISSING VALUES'' files. |
Methodology | |
| Purpose of the Study: | This study employed a factorial design whereby the police response to spouse assault acted as the independent variable. Models of domestic violence were developed using two competing theories: Victim Empowerment and Specific Deterrence. When an officer arrived at the scene of a domestic violence incident, a random treatment was assigned via radio dispatch. Officers had final authority over assignment, and could assign another treatment at their own discretion. Treatments included arresting the suspect, issuing an emergency protection order, referring the suspect to counseling, separating the suspect and the victim, and restoring order only (no specific action). A unique four-digit project ID number was assigned to each subject. It was possible for an individual to appear several times: as a victim in one case and a suspect in another -- as a victim or suspect in several cases with different partners -- or as a repeat case that was not properly screened. Follow-up interviews were conducted with victims at three- and six-month periods. Recidivists were identified through extensive police and court record checks, and victim empowerment data were collected with a validated survey instrument. |
| Study Design: | Variables from initial incident reports include number of charges, date, location, and disposition of charges, victim and suspect demographics, weapon(s) used, victim injuries, medical attention received, behavior towards police, and victim and suspect comments. Data collected from counseling forms provide information on suspect demographics, type of counseling, topics covered in counseling, suspect's level of participation, and therapist comments. Court records investigate victim and suspect criminal histories, including descriptions of charges and their disposition, conditions of pretrial release, and the victim's contact with pretrial services. Other variables included in follow-up checks focus on criminal and offense history of the suspect. |
| Sample: | All domestic violence calls made to the Colorado Springs Police Department were included in the sample. There were 1,202 cases in which the officer imposed a randomly assigned treatment, 315 cases in which the officer imposed a different treatment than the one assigned by the dispatcher, 31 cases that initially had multiple response data that were later clarified, and 110 cases that entered the project more than once during the six-month period. Two cases had multiple responses that could not be clarified. |
| Data Source: | personal interviews, counseling session forms, and police and court records |
| Mode of Data Collection: | Data were collected from (1) reports filed by police officers after the first contact, (2) follow-up interviews with victims at three- and six-month periods, (3) re-offense information from official police records, (4) counseling session forms filled out by suspects' therapists, (5) criminal history and victimization records, and (6) records from official court proceedings. |
| Response Rates: | Of the 1,150 cases in the project (excluding the repeat cases), 80 percent received an initial interview. Final interviews were completed on 1,079 (70 percent) of the 1,202 cases that received the randomly assigned treatment. |
| Presence of Common Scales: | None |
Access and Availability | |
| Note: | A list of the data formats available for this study can be found in the summary of holdings. Detailed file-level information (such as record length, case count, and variable count) is listed in the file manifest. |
| Original ICPSR Release: | 1994-06-03 |
| Version History: | The last update of this study occurred on 1994-06-03. |
| 2006-01-12 - All files were removed from dataset 44 and flagged as study-level files, so that they will accompany all downloads. | |
| 2006-01-12 - All files were removed from dataset 25 and flagged as study-level files, so that they will accompany all downloads. | |
| Dataset(s): |
|
